I Find This Pun to Be a Bit Dull

Favorite
pencil,good point,brand,good,point
- -

Punmaster Caitlin says: "You could make a pencil with an eraser on each end, but that would be pointless."

If by "pointless" you mean TOTALLY AND COMPLETELY AWESOME AND ENDLESSLY AMUSING, then yes, I agree with you 100 percent, Caitlin.

Lead Astray

Favorite
broken,dull,lead,pencil,point,pointless,tip
- -

That it Is...

Favorite
broken,cliché,double meaning,literalism,pencil,point,pointless
- -

Oh, what a terribly dull joke this truly is... - Matty Malaprop

Lame Drawn Coon

Favorite
DIY,double meaning,drawn,drawn out,handmade,Lame Pun Coon,meme,pencil,process
- -

And despite the care and nuance put into the effort, the results are sadly very black and white. - Matty Malaprop

Iambic Groantameter

Favorite
- -

Whenever this guy makes that dopey smile of his, I simply cannot help but King Lear at him. - Matty Malaprop

Reverend Al Sharpened

Favorite
al sharpton,juxtaposition,pencil,photoshop,reverend,sharpened,similar sounding
- -

Oh Pancake, You So Pencil-y!

Favorite
homophones,lead,number two,pencil,variations on a theme
- -

Seems to me like this friendship ended up pretty broken after Pepper snapped and started a graphite. - Matty Malaprop