Pie Rats of the Carrbeans!

Favorite
derp,derpy,Hall of Fame,jack sparrow,Johnny Depp,Pirate,Pirates of the Caribbean,Rage Comics,rage face
- -

We are very much alike, you and I. I and you. Potato. - Matty Malaprop

It's a Good Letter

Favorite
encyclopedia,Hall of Fame,letter,lolwut,Pirate,r,sound
- -

Understanding the nuances of the letter R in the pirate lexicon is really an ARRRRRRRRRtform in and of itself. - Matty Malaprop

File Under: Hilarious and Poorly Executed

Favorite
arr,hilarious,loling 5eva,lolwut,Pirate,poorly executed,prefix,terrible
- -

Seriously, this is sooooooooo bad (no offense creator!), from the art to the typos to the joke itself... and yet I may or may not be ROFLing IRL because of it? - Matty Malaprop

Call it a Mewtiny

Favorite
cat,out,one-eyed,me,similar sounding,Pirate,grumpy,meow
- -

This just goes to show you; there truly is no rhyme or reason to pirate (c)law. - Matty Malaprop

I can has MOAR funny LOLcats?

ARRR2-D2

Favorite
arr,double meaning,Hall of Fame,lego,literalism,Pirate,r2d2,sound,star wars
- -

Given how advanced the technology behind R2 is, I wouldn't be the least bit surprised if he was quite proficient at piracy. - Matty Malaprop