Paul McDonald's Jacket Totally Looks Like A Slipcover

Favorite
Paul McDonald's Jacket Totally Looks Like A Slipcover
- -

Paul McDonald's Jacket Totally Looks Like A Slipcover

Rumor Mill: "American Idol" contestants murder couches and wear their skins as trophies! Get "Entertainment Tonight" on the phone!!!

Scotty McCreery Totally Looks Like Alfred E. Neuman

Favorite
Scotty McCreery Totally Looks Like Alfred E. Neuman
- -

Scotty McCreery Totally Looks Like Alfred E. Neuman

The paragon of All Things I Don't Care About At All: Some dude from "American Idol" and the mascot of "Mad" magazine.

American Idol Hopeful Casey Abrams Totally Looks Like Yukon Cornelius

Favorite
American Idol Hopeful Casey Abrams Totally Looks Like Yukon Cornelius
- -

American Idol Hopeful Casey Abrams Totally Looks Like Yukon Cornelius

I don't watch "American Idol," but I would if instead of humans singing cover songs it was all about classic claymation Christmas characters competing to win the title of "Most Christmasy." They might have to change the name of the show, though...