Paul McDonald's Jacket Totally Looks Like A Slipcover
Rumor Mill: "American Idol" contestants murder couches and wear their skins as trophies! Get "Entertainment Tonight" on the phone!!!
Scotty McCreery Totally Looks Like Alfred E. Neuman
The paragon of All Things I Don't Care About At All: Some dude from "American Idol" and the mascot of "Mad" magazine.